top of page
Search
  • amyplotch

Why I'm Questioning the U.S. Approach to Freedom

I always try to make these blog posts interesting, entertaining and fun to read. Today is a little different.



A Korean friend recently shared with me her concerns about her upcoming move to the United States. “Is it really dangerous there?” she asked. “Does everyone have a gun?” Phil and I have fielded lots of questions about the anti-Asian bias attacks in the United States. This was a broader concern.


I explained that the United States is a huge and diverse country. While parts are dangerous, many areas are safe and enjoyable places to live. While parts are racist, others are tolerant and welcoming to newcomers. “You’ll be living in a beautiful university town,” I said. “You will be fine.”


Then I went home and read about the latest mass shooting in the United States. And I felt guilty about misleading her.


In South Korea you can walk down any street, at any hour, in any neighborhood and know that you will emerge safely. You don’t clutch your purse at a mall or a restaurant or outdoor concert. I’ve only seen one metal detector since we arrived here, and that was at the U.S. Embassy.


In 2019, 10 people died of gun injuries in South Korea; that same year 38,300 died in the United States.


It turns out that South Korea has some of the strictest gun laws of all developed nations. Koreans are allowed to own guns; sporting and hunting gun licenses are issued by the government. But guns must be stored at local police stations. People who fail to follow the laws face fines of $30,000–$150,000 and 3 to 15 years in prison.


The system here is certainly imperfect. There are signs pointing to CCTV cameras everywhere. (I don’t know if there are more cameras than in the United States or if they are just better marked.) There is also a stringent anti-defamation law. People can be charged with defamation even when they are telling the truth. The punishment is most severe when it involves online defamation. This means you aren’t allowed to insult someone or accuse them, even when you have evidence on your side. It definitely helps maintain decorum, but it also keeps powerful people in power, and it constrains their critics.


However, public safety makes the pursuit of happiness much easier. Phil and I have had our share of challenges and mishaps. There was the time we took a trip out of town, got stranded in a rural area and couldn’t figure out how to call a cab. But because we always feel safe, it feels like an adventure not a threat.


For all of America’s emphasis on constitutionally protected personal freedom, we haven’t given ourselves the freedom to feel safe. And that seems like an essential human right to me.

Recent Posts

See All

4 Comments


Randi Asher
Randi Asher
Apr 15, 2021

Very important reflections here, that make me a bit sad, to be honest. Our so called "US Freedom" leaves us fearful and constrained and with such loss of real freedom. The increase in AAPI Atttacks and racism is heartbreaking. And, I could go on about our lack of gun-control laws, for sure. Thank you for the thoughts. Keep exploring and enjoying. XO

Like

dbhufford
dbhufford
Apr 15, 2021

Terrific post, Amy. It highlights an issue that needs to be taken seriously in the US. Our focus on "personal freedom" can get so extreme that it actually reduces freedom to be safe and secure, from those who oppose even the most reasonable gun safety laws to those who fight against mask mandates or vaccination efforts, citing "personal freedom." Having read a number of US histories and biographies over the past view years, it is clear that this is part of our culture from our country's inception, and there are certainly negatives, not just positives, that flow from this that we need to consider. Enjoy South Korea!

Like
amyplotch
Apr 16, 2021
Replying to

Brian, another aspect of the Korean legal system that would interest you: anti-vaccine disinformation is illegal. Many people have been arrested for this.

Like

deborahevans
Apr 15, 2021

It is such a fabulous opportunity for you to experience another culture and certainly living in another country allows you to question with an open mind. Well done, I’m enjoying your posts, keep learning

Like
bottom of page